Communities › Fort Myers › Gateway

Cypress Cay

What has actually sold in Cypress Cay over the last twelve months, and what is on the market there today. It sits inside Gateway.

Median sale price
$415,500

across 11 sales in a year

See recent sales →
For sale now
1

on the market today

See them →

Days to sell
30

for the typical home

Of asking price
97.2%

what sellers actually got

Per square foot
$200

on the typical sale

Typical year built
2004

of homes that sold

What it takes to buy here

The middle half of sales landed between $393,000 and $445,000. Half of everything sold went under contract inside 30 days.

55% came with a pool, so being without one here is the exception and it shows up in the price.

Listings open in our search. The MLS requires an account before it will show you listing detail and sold prices, which takes a minute.

Before you offer on anything here

Your taxes reassess when you buy, so the seller's bill is not yours. Insurance depends on the roof and the flood zone. Both matter more than the price you negotiate.

Questions people ask about Cypress Cay

How much do homes in Cypress Cay sell for?

The median sale in Cypress Cay over the last twelve months was $415,500, across 11 closings. The middle half landed between $393,000 and $445,000. There are 1 homes for sale there today.

How long does it take to sell in Cypress Cay?

Half of what sold went under contract within 30 days. Sellers got 97.2% of what they asked. A home sitting far longer than that is usually telling you something about its price rather than about the neighbourhood.

Also in Fort Myers

Stoneybrook

$395,000

37 sales · 17 for sale

Hampton Park

$547,500

30 sales · 13 for sale

Daniels Preserve

$447,500

22 sales · 4 for sale

Royal Greens

$154,000

21 sales · 3 for sale

Mahogany Run

$560,000

13 sales · 3 for sale

Summerwind

$180,000

13 sales · 10 for sale

Thinking about Cypress Cay?

Numbers will not tell you which streets flood or which association is about to assess. Ring and ask.

(239) 420-9027 Send a message

Aggregated from Florida Gulf Coast Multiple Listing Service data, twelve months of closed sales filtered to homes. Information is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by the MLS. A median is not a valuation of any particular property. Rebuilt 2026-09-05.